Freeballers
- RBLaDainian Tomlinson
- WRLarry Fitzgerald
- QBDonovan McNabb
- WRPlaxico Burress
- —Lee Evans
- —Terry Glenn
- —Cedric Benson
- QBMatt Schaub
- QBRex Grossman
- RBChris Henry
- —Jeff Wilkins
- DSTEagles
- QBMike Vick
- WRRonald Curry
- RBMike Bell
Kibbitz Killers
- RBSteven Jackson
- WRReggie Wayne
- QBTony Romo
- RBDeAngelo Williams
- RBJoseph Addai
- WRSantana Moss
- QBPhilip Rivers
- WRMuhsin Muhammad
- TEBenjamin Watson
- WRMatt Jones
- —Nate Kaeding
- TEL.J. Smith
- QBDamon Huard
- RBTony Hunt
- DSTPackers
Kansas City Funnelers
- RBShaun Alexander
- —Terrell Owens
- RBJamal Lewis
- RBJulius Jones
- WRReggie Brown
- QBJ.P. Losman
- WRVincent Jackson
- QBDaunte Culpepper
- DSTChargers
- —Randy McMichael
- QBVince Young
- —Eric Moulds
- WRTed Ginn
- KStephen Gostkowski
- RBBrandon Jacobs
Downtown Rockville
- QBPeyton Manning
- —Marvin Harrison
- TEAntonio Gates
- WRRandy Moss
- QBBen Roethlisberger
- TETony Gonzalez
- RBChester Taylor
- DSTJaguars
- RBLaurence Maroney
- TEKellen Winslow
- DSTJets
- QBBrodie Croyle
- KShayne Graham
- —Lorenzo Booker
- RBMaurice Jones-Drew
Pre-Teen Spacedockers
- RBLarry Johnson
- WRTorry Holt
- QBJon Kitna
- RBBrandon Jackson
- WRT.J. Houshmandzadeh
- RBLadell Betts
- QBChad Pennington
- —Trent Green
- —Byron Leftwich
- DSTSteelers
- WRDrew Bennett
- RBMarion Barber
- WRDwayne Jarrett
- KJason Elam
- WRMichael Clayton
Bacon Brothers
- —Travis Henry
- QBMarc Bulger
- WRRoy Williams
- RBJerious Norwood
- RBFrank Gore
- QBDrew Brees
- WRJoey Galloway
- WRJerricho Cotchery
- WRD.J. Hackett
- —Jerry Porter
- —Michael Robinson FB
- WRBrandon Marshall
- RBChris Brown
- RBLenDale White
- —Cecil Sapp
Dumb Luck
- RBBrian Westbrook
- WRSteve Smith
- QBTom Brady
- —Fred Taylor
- WRLaveranues Coles
- RBLaMont Jordan
- WRDeion Branch
- TEAlge Crumpler
- WRBernard Berrian
- WRGreg Jennings
- WRDerrick Mason
- DSTColts
- RBCorrell Buckhalter
- KMatt Stover
- RBLeon Washington
Log Jammin'
- —Rudi Johnson
- RBMarshawn Lynch
- RBAhman Green
- QBBrett Favre
- WRHines Ward
- —Darrell Jackson
- QBJeff Garcia
- RBThomas Jones
- WRJoe Horn
- —Chris Cooley
- WRBrandon Jones
- RBKevin Jones
- DSTDolphins
- WRMike Williams
- QBJason Campbell
Budwin's Team
- RBRonnie Brown
- —Chad Johnson
- WRAnquan Boldin
- —Tatum Bell
- —Donald Driver
- QBAlex Smith
- DSTBears
- —Warrick Dunn
- QBJoey Harrington
- —Anthony Thomas
- TEVernon Davis
- QBBrady Quinn
- WRAnthony Gonzalez
- WRWes Welker
- —Neil Rackers
Sweet Wizard Team
- RBWillis McGahee
- RBClinton Portis
- WRJavon Walker
- QBEli Manning
- WRCalvin Johnson
- RBDeuce McAllister
- —Steve McNair
- WRBraylon Edwards
- —Todd Heap
- DSTBroncos
- KAdam Vinatieri
- QBTarvaris Jackson
- TEJason Witten
- —Vernand Morency
- WRDevery Henderson
Sloppy Seconds
- QBCarson Palmer
- RBEdgerrin James
- RBAdrian Peterson
- WRAndre Johnson
- WRMark Clayton
- —DeShaun Foster
- WRChris Chambers
- DSTPatriots
- WRSantonio Holmes
- WRIsaac Bruce
- WRTroy Williamson
- QBMatt Leinart
- WRMike Furrey
- RBDominic Rhodes
- QBJay Cutler
Shart Suckers
- RBReggie Bush
- RBWillie Parker
- RBCadillac Williams
- QBMatt Hasselbeck
- QBJake Delhomme
- WRDonte' Stallworth
- TEJeremy Shockey
- DSTRavens
- WRKevin Curtis
- —Michael Turner
- WREddie Kennison
- WRReggie Williams
- WRBrandon Stokley
- KRobbie Gould
- WRMarques Colston